This article originally appeared in
Tuesday, September 25, 2001 Page G-1
Defense Need Will Not End Tax Cuts,
Italian Prime Minister Promises
ROME--Despite promises to reach European Union deficit targets while increasing defense spending in the
wake of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks in the United States, Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi has vowed that Italy
will not raise recently reduced corporate and individual taxes.
The pledge not to raise taxes came amid widespread speculation that Berlusconi's rhetoric about increasing
defense spending while maintaining EU fiscal targets will force the government to back away from 2002 tax
breaks promised earlier in the year. But Berlusconi, who has been in office since June, said that would not take
A spokesman for the prime minister's office told BNA Sept. 21 that funding for the increased defense spending
would come from cuts to other departments, though the spokesman did not elaborate. The government is yet to
say how much it will increase defense spending or to detail how the extra funds will be used.
"The details have not been finalized, but the target is to use existing funds in a different manner that will allow
us to increase defense spending without having an impact on targets for deficit reduction and taxes," the
Details of Tax Cuts Not Yet Revealed
Vito Tanzi, an undersecretary at the Italian Treasury, appeared on television Sept. 22 to reiterate vows that Italy
would continue work toward a previously stated government debt target of 0.8 percent of gross domestic
product this year and 0.5 percent in 2002. However, he also took the opportunity to state that there were no
plans to raise taxes because of the current uncertain world economic situation.
Though the exact nature of the tax cuts will not be published until the official budget is unveiled late in 2001,
Berlusconi and other members of his government have painted it in broad strokes.
The major pillar of the tax break plan is an initiative to reward companies that reinvest profits with a deduction of
up to 50 percent of the reinvested figure if it is above the average amount of reinvested profits for that company
over the previous five years. That initiative, the so-called Tremonti Law named for economist and Finance
Minister Giulio Tremonti, was first proposed when Berlusconi was prime minister seven years ago and was
updated and proposed again in July.
The new version is wider reaching than the 1994 version, which included a narrow definition of the word
"reinvestment" and covered only certain industries. Instead, the new initiative covers virtually any business,
including insurance companies, retailers, banks, and the self-employed, and regards any kind of research,
training, infrastructure and development costs as allowable reinvestments.
Incentives for Slowest Growing EU Economy
The Tremonti Law is aimed at sparking growth. Government estimates in July showed that Italy's annual growth
rate would rise 0.2 percent in 2002 and 0.3 percent in 2003 as a result of the incentives--a welcome trend in
what is traditionally the EU's slowest growing economy. Critics, however, wonder if the government could be
spreading its resources too thin.
The tax relief that is part of the Tremonti Law is part of a broader $30 billion, 10-year tax break plan Berlusconi
promised during his campaign. Berlusconi also promised to fund infrastructure projects worth some $5 billion,
while paying down debt levels that are the second highest in the European Union in GDP terms. Add to that the
increased defense spending Berlusconi has promised in the wake of the U.S. attacks, and many experts see a
"The government says it will increase spending and decrease taxes and they have not yet said where the
money will come from," Francesco Caetani, a former Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
consultant, told BNA Sept. 24.
Confindustria, Italy's leading employers' association and a strong advocate of the Tremonti Law and other parts
of the tax reduction package, said it is taking the prime minister at his word when he says he will not raise taxes.
"We have no reason to doubt the government's willingness to encourage growth by reducing the corporate tax
burden," a spokesman told BNA on Sept. 21. "This is a key part of the government's strategy, and those who say
it may be canceled are only speculating."
By Eric J. Lyman
Contact customer relations at: email@example.com or 1-800-372-1033
Copyright © 2001, The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc.
Reproduction or redistribution, in whole or in part, and in any form,
without express written permission, is prohibited except as permitted by the BNA Copyright Policy,